Essential
question: How do you make decisions about your own actions for students in
a differentiated classroom? What is your criteria for intervention, and/or for
letting learning happen?
I do
not have my own classroom right now, so I am thinking more hypothetical and for
the future. This first question is kind of confusing for me and really made me
think. I think the question is asking, how I decide what students should be
doing in a differentiated classroom. This gets right into getting to know your
students and understanding where they are in the learning process. It is
important to remember that, “differentiation
doesn’t suggest that a teacher can be all things to all individuals all the
time. It does, however, mandate that a teacher create a reasonable range of
approaches to learning much of the time, so that most students find learning a
fit much of the time” (Tomlinson 2001 pg.17). Approaches will be different for
every teacher, for me it usually involves including videos, websites, in person
examples, and written examples. “The reality is that every teacher already
has the tools to differentiate in powerful ways for all learners” (McCarthy
2014, p.2).
How
do I let learning happen in a differentiate classroom?
“When teachers differentiate instruction,
they move away from seeing themselves as keepers and dispensers of knowledge
and move toward seeing themselves as organizers of learning opportunities”
(Tomlinson 2001 pg.16) This statement is similar to a TED talk I watch by
Sugata Mitra, he talked about his research with third world children and he
talked about how these students who did not have school where able to learn. He
explained that one reason this could happen was because they were encouraged. Mitra
said, “learning as the product of educational self-organization. It’s not about
making learning happen, it’s about letting learning happen”. He also said “the teacher
only raises the question, and then stands back and admires the answer”. I think
this is exactly what we are trying to make happen in our classes. Giving students
tools, support, and a basis and then letting them figure it out on their own. I
think the hardest part about letting students learn is that it takes time and
it never seems like there is enough time in the school day. I read an article by Adora Svitak and she
talked a little bit about getting students involved in real issues. This would
be easier the older students get, but I can see there being a few things that elementary
students could do. When I was in high school my favorite and most memorable
class was an English class that was all about participating in Model United
Nations. We learned about child soldiers, sex trafficking, and fair trade. This
may seem like a lot for high school students, but it was the most involved and
excited I had ever been about school. One way I might do this with older students
would be to give them a topic and let them research for a few days and then
have the class share what they learned as a group. Leading up to this would
need to be lessons about legitimate websites and looking past the first page of
google, but it could be a way to mix up the day to day lessons.
References
Bubbl (n.d.). Mind Mapping. Retreived from https://bubbl.us
McCarthy, J. (2014, July 23). 3 Ways
to Plan for Diverse Learners: What Teachers Do. Retrieved January 25, 2017,
from https://www.edutopia.org/blog/differentiated-instruction-ways-to-plan-john-mccarthy
Mitra, S. (2013, February).
Retrieved January 25, 2017, from http://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_build_a_school_in_the_cloud
Svitak, A. (2012, February 08). 5
Ways to Empower Students. Retrieved January 25, 2017, from https://www.edutopia.org/blog/empower-students-adora-svitak
Tomlinson, C. A. (2001). How to Differentiate
Instruction in Mixed-ability Classrooms. Alexandria, Va: Assoc. for Supervision
and Curriculum Development.
For someone who isn't currently in a classroom, I think your comments are quite insightful! Knowing that you cannot be all things to all people, but that you have a reasonable "range of approaches" (Tomlinson, 2001, p.17), is a step up on most. Furthermore, when you understand you already have access to/understand the processes that work for each student, you're essentially acknowledging that you possess the tools necessary to differentiate and ensure the success of each student (McCarthy 2015). That is a powerful knowledge, indeed.
ReplyDeleteOne thing I would encourage you to consider, in light of the question, is in the process of applying these approaches, when you will step in to help a struggling student and when you give them time to struggle? I talked about it a bit in my blog, but I think it's good to think, before you face the students, about how you will reply when they ask for help. Too often, because we're so focused on ensuring our students learn the content, we forget that when they struggle to learn something (and succeed), they not only build confidence in their ability, they also experience lasting learning because they had to work for the answer.
References
McCarthy, J. (August 28, 2015). 3 ways to plan for diverse learners: What teachers do. Edutopia. Retrieved from https://www.edutopia.org/blog/differentiated-instruction-ways-to-plan-john-mccarthy
Tomlinson, C. (2001). How to differentiate instruction in mixed-ability classrooms (2nd ed.). Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Thank you for your incite. I took a couple courses with Susan Andrews last semester and she really encouraged us as teachers to not give in to students who are looking for ques that they got something right. Such as with reading, when a student sounds out a word and then waits for the teacher to say yes or try again. If the student is not able to figure out what they think or if they are right or wrong then they are not truly learning the information. It can definitely be more challenging then this, but I think this is also good to keep in mind for most subjects. Sometimes having the confidence to decide if you are right or wrong is half of the battle.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteStand back and let learning happen what a reflection of effective teaching. Of the creation of an effective environment for learning. If we are able to present the idea and have a class with students confident enough to engage the topic within themselves and with each other then I believe we have created a wonderful masterpiece of art.
ReplyDeleteI am however challenged by your response about not giving ques to students in response of success or the need to try again. Coming from a very negative family my teachers, especially at the age of learning to read, were my only encouragement to strive to do things right. I will have to contemplate this idea more. I am sure there are many ways of teaching.
Doody discusses the importance of reflection of ourselves as teachers (pp 563, 2013). Questions are also presented as a launching point of self inquire. I believe with this type of implementation finding what works will come into focus more clearly for you. As one who has worked with a different population from my own and implemented various types of reflection I have learned how to relate in a more effective way. From a cultural stand point working with Yup'ik population to praise someone in open is not appropriate as it can cause disputes and jealousy. This idea was challenging in the beginning however not much anymore as I have learned how to meet the learner where they are in most situations through previously mentioned reflection.
Doody, O. S. & Condon, M. (2013). Using a simulated environment to support student learning clinical skills. Nursing Education in Practice. pp.561-566.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2013.03.011
Not giving ques is hard for me as well. Its not that the teacher never gives praise, but that the praise is sincere and not blanketed. I was often finding myself saying good job, great, or wonderful. These are not specific to what the student has done. So, instead of saying great, the teacher might say "it looks like you worked really hard on that." There is a book "Opening Minds" by Peter H. Johnston. It is an insightful and eye opening book.
DeleteI really appreciate the comment you made that to effectively have differentiated instruction teachers must become organizers of learning versus the traditional role of providing information. Interesting enough this puts the responsibility of learning on the students which provides a more authentic learning experience. What I struggle with as a teacher is those students who refuse to participate and not be responsible for their learning. One of the ways to address this is by guiding the learning to be interesting to the student even if this means taking time away from learning the standards or what is "supposed" to be learned at this moment. In my Pre-Algebra, I take way longer than needed on the concepts of probability because of many reasons but mainly students love talking about the probability of events happening and how this might effect their everyday life.
ReplyDeleteHow else do you think we can support and organize learning for those students who are not capable of learning at that moment because of trauma or for those students who do not care for the education they are receiving?